You're Gonna Die
2010-06-21 · John · watch on YouTube · Philosophy & meaning · reflection essay
Answering Hank's video on The Game, John says everyone and everything will be forgotten, but that is not nihilistic: we cannot choose whether to lose or to care, only what to care about, so he chooses nerdfighting, books and the World Cup; he then hosts a World Cup edition of Truth or Fail.
What is said
00:00:00 — You're gonna die and everything will be forgotten; at the Orlando Science Center planetarium as a kid John learned the Earth will end
- ★★★ John tells Hank they and everyone they love will die, and one day no one will remember the books, World Cups, proofs or in-your-pants jokes, as if they never happened. — 00:00:00 · in your pants
- ★★ John recalls learning as a child at the Orlando Science Center planetarium that the Earth will end, his first grappling with the temporary habitability of the universe. — 00:00:24
- ★★ John says, unsure and admitting he's not good at science, that in about six billion years the Earth will fall into the sun. (hedged) — 00:00:27
- number check: about six billion — doubtful
00:00:52 — Hank's Friday video was optimistic: we choose which games to care about; John's criteria; all this is temporary but we have a say
- ★★ Some think talking about death and the temporariness of human experience is pessimistic or nihilistic, but John found Hank's Friday video on games, losing and non-attachment quite optimistic. — 00:00:52
- ★★★ Restating Hank, John says we don't choose whether we lose the games we play, but we choose which games; we can't choose whether to care, only what to care about. — 00:01:04 > «We don't get to choose whether to care but we do get to choose what to care about.»
- ★★★ When he cares about a game, John asks whether it helps people here now, honors those who came before, and paves the way for those who come after. — 00:01:18
- ★★★ John says all this is temporary, but we have a say in how temporary it is. — 00:01:29
00:01:32 — An anglerfish gift; John chooses nerdfighting, books and the World Cup; argument with himself about 'the same ball'
- ★ John shows an anglerfish someone gave him and calls it cute. (playful) — 00:01:32
- ★★★ John chooses nerdfighting, books and, though it's silly, the World Cup, because it transcends geography, ethnicity, wealth and politics and puts the world on the same grass. — 00:01:36 · nerdfighter
00:02:07 — Grateful to Hank; a World Cup Truth or Fail to make Hank a football fan; sign-off
- ★★ Hank's video didn't change John's mind about watching the World Cup, but made him think about why he cares about soccer and reminded him caring is a choice; he is grateful. — 00:02:07
- ★★ Inspired by Hank, John makes a World Cup episode of Truth or Fail, hoping to turn Hank into a football fan. (hedged) — 00:02:17 · Truth or Fail
00:02:33 — Truth or Fail World Cup edition: John watches Spain v Switzerland, his streak since 1994, the rules, two purported facts
- ★★ Hosting Truth or Fail while watching Spain play Switzerland, John says he has watched every World Cup match since 1994 and won't break the streak. (playful) — 00:02:38
- ★★ Truth or Fail option one, one of two purported facts: the US goal against England in the 1950 World Cup 'Miracle on Grass' was scored not by an American but by a Haitian. — 00:02:57 · United States, Haiti, Truth or Fail
- ★★ Truth or Fail option two: the term 'soccer' derives from early football players often playing in their socks rather than cleats. — 00:03:08 · Truth or Fail
Humor (significant)
- John opens his Monday letter to Hank with an ordinary greeting, then a pause. — 00:00:00 > «you're gonna die.»
- Told the Earth's end is a long way away, eight-year-old John reasons the teacher is old but he might yet live that long. — 00:00:43 > «It's very plausible that with advances in medical science I could live for six billion years!»
- A second John objects that a World Cup match takes more than one ball, and John explains he avoided saying 'balls'. — 00:01:50 > «By the way, who's the lucky guy who gets to have the pair of balls that the whole world plays with?»
- John explains Truth or Fail: click the true fact, or click the wrong one and... — 00:02:48 > «and fail worse than England at a World Cup penalty shootout.»
Threads in this video
- callback · 'In your pants' suffix game (2007) — John lists the in-your-pants jokes the brothers made among the things no one will remember. (00:00:16)
- refine · Does human life have real meaning, given oblivion, cosmic scale and an indifferent universe? — John: we will all die and be forgotten, but that is not nihilistic; we can't choose whether to care, only what to care about, and we have a say in how temporary things are. (00:01:04)
- restate · Can things that humans made up (sports, money, borders, rules) really matter? — John: though it's silly, he chooses to care about the World Cup because it transcends geography, ethnicity, wealth and politics. (00:01:36)
- milestone · Truth or Fail game-show videos (2009) — John hosts a World Cup edition of Truth or Fail at the end of his video, inspired by Hank's video. (00:02:17)
Replies to
- You just lost THE GAME! — «your video on Friday»
BR2_485151407e