Skip to content

Opinions over time

Each question is a stance the brothers return to. shift/revise = the position moved; tension = disagreement with the other brother. Only sincere or hedged statements are recorded as positions.

question John Hank span changes
What is the community for? 18 9 2007–2013
Which candidate is best in a given presidential race? 8 14 2007–2011 9
Should ideas be ownable, and is copyright law working? 8 8 2007–2013 1
Is there really an 'us' and a 'them', or are distant and different people just facets of us? 11 5 2007–2013 1
What makes a good romantic relationship or friendship? 12 4 2008–2013 1
Is it reasonable to be hopeful about the future? 8 6 2007–2013 2
Should LGBTQ people be fully accepted, with equal rights including marriage? 6 8 2007–2013
Does human life have real meaning, given oblivion, cosmic scale and an indifferent universe? 8 6 2009–2013
How should online creators be paid: ads, sponsorships, paywalls or direct audience support? 6 8 2009–2013
Can we imagine other people complexly, and what stops us? 7 6 2008–2012
Should everyone be guaranteed health care? 9 3 2008–2013
Why make things? 6 5 2007–2012
Do people achieve more together than as individuals? 4 7 2007–2013
Is the internet a real place, and is online life real life? 6 5 2007–2013
Is ad-supported media good for audiences and society? 4 7 2009–2013
Is microfinance an effective way to fight poverty? 7 3 2007–2013
Does government work well? 6 4 2010–2013
Should the penny (and other low-value money) be abolished? 10 0 2010–2013
Do individual green choices matter? 2 7 2007–2011
Is unironic enthusiasm better than being cool? 6 3 2007–2013
How serious is climate change? 3 6 2007–2013
Is the internet, including social media, good for people? 5 4 2008–2013
What is art for? 8 1 2008–2013 1
Can things that humans made up (sports, money, borders, rules) really matter? 6 3 2009–2012
Is consumerism harmful, and are gifts worth giving? 5 3 2007–2012
Can business do good, or does business have to suck? 5 3 2009–2013
Should schools and libraries restrict books? 4 3 2007–2012
How should we replace fossil fuels? 0 7 2007–2013
What is the community's charity drive for: attention for causes, money, or the community itself? 2 5 2007–2011
Does the author's intent matter to what a work means? 7 0 2007–2013
What makes charity or aid work well? 3 4 2008–2013
Do people get what they deserve, or do luck and privilege decide? 5 2 2009–2013
What is school for? 5 2 2009–2012
Should language follow fixed rules of correct usage? 5 2 2010–2013
Is fame good for the people who have it? 4 2 2007–2013
Should people follow gender norms? 4 2 2007–2012
Is human life getting better; is now the best time to be alive? 3 3 2010–2013
Do revolutions lead to good outcomes? 5 1 2010–2013
Is space exploration worth the cost? 1 5 2011–2012
Can a dictatorship be benign? 4 1 2007–2013
Can imagination and work make ideas real? 3 2 2008–2013
Do big problems have simple solutions? 4 1 2010–2013
What do editors do, and is a book one person's work? 5 0 2011–2013
What is work for, and how much should people work? 2 2 2007–2012
What makes a good video? 2 2 2007–2013
Must a film adaptation be faithful to the book? 4 0 2007–2013
What counts as real reading: do YA, children's books, audiobooks and e-readers count? 2 2 2007–2011
Can online video truly educate, or only inform? 1 3 2007–2012
Should people trust scientific consensus? 2 2 2007–2013
Can appearance reveal what a person is like? 0 4 2007–2011
Which causes deserve the most support? 4 0 2008–2011
Can news media be trusted to inform us accurately? 2 2 2009–2012
Does God exist, and is religious faith worth having? 3 1 2009–2011
Is evil found only in certain people, or in all of us? 2 2 2009–2013
Is nostalgia trustworthy: were earlier times, or earlier generations, really better? 3 1 2009–2011
Are human interests and nature in conflict, or are humans part of nature? 0 4 2009–2013 1
Do money and success bring happiness? 1 3 2010–2012
Is failure valuable? 1 3 2010–2012
Is adulthood a destination you arrive at? 2 2 2011–2013
Is learning worthwhile for its own sake? 2 2 2012–2013
Is extreme wealth, and the tax system that protects it, a problem? 1 3 2012–2013
Should powerful countries intervene militarily abroad? 0 3 2007–2013
Can writing be taught? 2 1 2007–2008
What do humans owe animals (pets, livestock, wild animals)? 1 2 2007–2010
Does one vote matter? 2 1 2008–2012
How should creators respond to hateful comments and criticism? 1 2 2008–2009
Does every living thing have moral value just for being alive, and can a life be priced? 0 3 2009–2013
Is patriotism a virtue? 1 2 2009–2013
Is outrage useful? 0 3 2009–2013
Is death fair, and should we accept mortality? 0 3 2010–2013
Does suffering have meaning, or is it mostly unnecessary harm to be reduced? 2 1 2010–2012
Do spoilers ruin a story for readers and viewers? 2 1 2011–2011 1
Is political polarization caused by structures (districts, rules, incentives) rather than by people? 2 1 2012–2013
What is the greatest or most distinctive human quality? 2 1 2013–2013 1
Can a source that anyone can edit be trusted? 1 1 2007–2007
Do people become wiser or more foolish as they grow older? 0 2 2007–2012
Does having influence (role model, big platform) bring special responsibility? 1 1 2007–2007
Do good ends justify bad means? 1 1 2007–2007
Who should be allowed to take part in a country's political process (minors, non-citizens)? 1 1 2007–2007 1
Is democracy in danger? 2 0 2007–2013
Should creators get a share of the revenue whenever their work earns money, whatever the format? 2 0 2007–2013
Is history inevitable, or made by choices? 2 0 2009–2009
Is colonialism to blame for present-day wars and state failure in former colonies? 1 1 2009–2011
Do platforms treat creators and viewers fairly? 1 1 2009–2009
Can election results be trusted? 2 0 2009–2009
Are good books made in revision rather than in a fast first draft? 2 0 2009–2010
Should people care about strangers as much as about their family and those close to them? 1 1 2010–2010
Is college worth it? 2 0 2010–2012
Is there intelligent life beyond Earth? 0 2 2010–2010
Does science diminish wonder? 0 2 2010–2012
Why study history? 1 1 2010–2013
Can extreme poverty be ended, or are poor countries stuck? 1 1 2011–2013
What do the living owe the dead and those not yet born? 1 1 2011–2013
What is life, and what kinds of systems count as alive? 1 1 2011–2011 1
How should people cope with being bullied? 1 1 2011–2013
Should people fear terrorism? 1 1 2011–2011
Is change good? 1 1 2012–2012
Is ideology harmful to good politics? 2 0 2012–2013
Should people worry about what others think of them? 1 1 2012–2013
Can statistics build empathy, or do we need individual stories? 1 1 2013–2013
Should people have children? 0 1 2007–2007
Is trying to make the world better worth the risk of accidentally making it worse? 1 0 2007–2007
Should private ownership of guns and explosives be restricted? 1 0 2007–2007
Should economic growth be the measure of a society's success? 1 0 2007–2007
Is physical fighting ever an appropriate way to communicate or settle conflict? 0 1 2007–2007
Should governments cut taxes and raise spending to fight a deep recession? 1 0 2009–2009
Is compassion a weakness, or a strength, in people and in politics? 0 1 2009–2009
Should doctors' pay depend on the treatments they recommend? 0 1 2009–2009
Should parents share their children's lives online? 1 0 2010–2010
Should people trust their gut instincts over reasoning? 1 0 2010–2010
Is online video a new kind of medium, or old entertainment delivered a new way? 0 1 2010–2010
Can a quotation or passage be understood without its context? 1 0 2010–2010
Can humans build artificial intelligence? 0 1 2010–2010
Should conjoined twins be separated at birth? 1 0 2010–2010
Should net neutrality be law? 0 1 2010–2010
Should industries whose risks fall on shared resources regulate themselves, or be regulated by government? 0 1 2010–2010
Does holding power favour people who do not care about others? 0 1 2011–2011
Is a large human population the cause of the world's problems? 0 1 2011–2011
Can a person really change who they are? 0 1 2011–2011
Is tipping a good way to reward service and pay service workers? 0 1 2011–2011
Is technology morally neutral, good or bad only in how people use it? 0 1 2012–2012
Why do people seek out fear and the unknown (exploring, reading, horror)? 1 0 2012–2012
Do books engage us more deeply than other media (TV, film, YouTube)? 1 0 2012–2012 1
What makes someone a good parent? 1 0 2013–2013
Should countries give concessions to states that make threats? 0 1 2013–2013
Can the human will be broken, or is the human spirit indomitable? 1 0 2013–2013
Is a moral sense innate, or learned from one's world? 1 0 2013–2013
Is natural better than artificial? 0 1 2013–2013
Do people wield power, or does power wield (change) the people who hold it? 1 0 2013–2013
What makes a good apology? 0 1 2013–2013