Optimism is Not Insane
2013-05-31 · Hank · watch on YouTube · Global development · reflection essay
Hank says his earlier video on humanity's impact on Earth was paralyzing and wrong in spirit: our brains overweight bad news, humans keep solving problems together, and working for a better future comes from optimism.
What is said
00:00:00 — Pre-congratulations on John's baby; jokes about John relaxing on paternity leave while Hank fixes the world
- ★★ Hank pre-congratulates John on his baby, due any day, and jokes that John will be relaxing on paternity leave while Hank fixes all the world's problems. (playful) — 00:00:00 · John Green
00:00:25 — Earlier Earth-impact video failed; cognitive biases toward bad news; humanity is not a cancer; health-and-wealth graph; we adapt; we are the superhero together
- ★★★ Hank says his video a few weeks ago on humanity's dramatic changes to the Earth, meant to inform and inspire, miserably failed: it was overwhelming, made people hate being human, and paralyzed them. (hedged) — 00:00:25
- ★★★ Hank says our brains are bad at this: we overestimate our ability to handle what we control and underestimate our ability as a species to affect what we can't control individually. — 00:00:49
- ★ Hank jokes that he thinks he can run five businesses and pop over to Seattle to help kickstart a space telescope without going crazy. (playful) — 00:00:56 · Seattle
- ★★★ Hank cites a known cognitive bias: we remember and decide based on negative experiences more than positive ones; it takes about 10 positive experiences to outweigh each negative one. — 00:01:08
- ★★★ Hank says you are being lied to by your own brain, by society and Fox News, and to some extent by him in his earlier video. — 00:01:18
- ★★★ Hank says humanity is not a cancer: deforestation happens because people want better lives for their families, and rivers run dry because we irrigate crops so children don't starve. — 00:01:26 > «Humanity is not a cancer!»
- ★★★ Hank says humans constantly solve huge problems without noticing or celebrating: disasters happen all at once, while successes come slowly and continue despite disasters. — 00:01:35
- ★★★ Showing a graph of health and wealth of every country from 1900 to 2011, Hank says every country is better off, and some African countries now do better than the US did in 1900. — 00:01:51 · United States
- ★★★ Hank thinks we see a graph rising toward a disaster point and assume we have only years left, but usually we adapt: capitalism, technology and even Congress adapt. (hedged) — 00:02:04 · climate change, United States Congress
- ★★★ Hank says every year we avoid the apocalypse not through one superhero but by working together as activists, scientists, writers, politicians and even bureaucrats: we are the superhero, together. — 00:02:27 · collective action > «We are the superhero! None of us individually, but all of us together.»
00:02:51 — Trip to Seattle's Museum of Flight to help launch Planetary Resources' space-telescope Kickstarter
- ★★ Hank's trip to Seattle's Museum of Flight to help Planetary Resources launch its space-telescope Kickstarter inspired him: crowdfunding a telescope, artifacts of great shared projects, dedicated people. — 00:02:51 · Seattle
00:03:20 — All of us working together; better futures come from optimism; sign-off
- ★★★ Hank says it is not just super-smart people but all of us working together to make the world work; we are good at solving problems, but they do not solve themselves. — 00:03:20 · collective action
- ★★★ Hank concludes that working for a better future comes not from wanting to avoid an inevitable apocalypse but from optimism, and there are a tremendous number of things to be optimistic about. — 00:03:30
Threads in this video
- update · John's paternity leave from vlogbrothers, with guest hosts filling in (2013) — Hank jokes that John will be relaxing on his paternity leave (sleeping, reading pretentious novels, eating fancy waffles) while his baby is due any day. (00:00:05)
- remind · John asks Hank to fix online video's dependence on advertising during his paternity leave (2013) — Hank thanks John for 'several impossible tasks' and says he is happy to fix all the world's problems during John's paternity leave. (00:00:21)
- revise · Are human interests and nature in conflict, or are humans part of nature? — Hank revises his earlier video on humanity's impact on Earth: it was paralyzing; humanity is not a cancer, as deforestation and dry rivers come from people trying to feed and better their families. (00:01:26)
- new · Is human life getting better; is now the best time to be alive? — Hank: a graph of health and wealth from 1900 to 2011 shows every country better off; humans constantly solve huge problems but never notice. (00:01:51)
- restate · Do people achieve more together than as individuals? — Hank: we avoid the apocalypse not through one superhero but by doing things together; we are the superhero, none of us individually but all of us together. (00:02:47)
- tell · Hank helps Planetary Resources launch its space-telescope Kickstarter at Seattle's Museum of Flight (2013) — Hank went to Seattle's Museum of Flight to help Planetary Resources launch its space-telescope Kickstarter and found it inspiring. (00:02:51)
- restate · Is it reasonable to be hopeful about the future? — Hank: working for a better future comes from optimism, not from fear of an inevitable apocalypse; there are a tremendous number of things to be optimistic about. (00:03:30)
Replies to
- NERD FACTOR! (...And Why I Fear for Tumblr) — «thank you for providing me with several impossible tasks to acomplish while you're»
- Some Mind-Bending Earth GIFs — «a few weeks ago I made a video that»
BR2_63dc4812ee