Skip to content

Is unironic enthusiasm better than being cool?

Axis: earnest enthusiasm ... ironic detachment / cool

John

date change position video
2007-07-25 new Answering comments that call the brothers nerds and dorky, John embraces the label ('We're nerds') and tells a 'get a life, nerd' commenter that being a nerdfighter is a good thing. July 25: Brotherhood 2.0's Youtube Comments Are Answered! 00:00:50
2007-07-27 restate John asks why being a nerd is bad, since calling someone a nerd means they would rather be intelligent and thoughtful than stupid and vapid. July 27: How Nerdfighters Drop Insults 00:01:01
2009-05-25 restate John praises LeakyCon people's unironic caring and says a hyper-cynical world forgets it's okay to get enthusiastic. WROCK! 00:00:29
2009-07-20 restate John says what he loves about being a nerd is being allowed to be unironically enthusiastic, and that calling someone a nerd just means 'you like stuff'. Harry Potter Nerds Win at Life 00:01:10
2010-04-16 restate John endorses Hank's point that nerdfighting is important but needs to be fun, and makes a fun video in response. The Patron Saint of Youtube 00:00:00
2012-01-17 restate John says it feels magical to be in a room of people unembarrassed of their enthusiasm and intellect. Thoughts from Places: The Tour 00:01:57

Hank

date change position video
2007-11-17 new Hank says it is important not to be afraid to get excited at things like the auto show. November 16th: Green Cars at the LA Auto Show 00:03:00
2010-04-15 restate Hank argues important does not mean serious and that fun ('important fun') is what new media should be about, not serious business. Fun is Important. Being Serious Isn't 00:01:06
2013-05-03 restate Hank defends enthusiastic novices against fans who say not knowing all the trivia makes you not a fan. 17 Rants in 4 Minutes 00:01:43