Introducing Subbable
2013-07-26 · Hank · watch on YouTube · Projects · announcement promotion
Hank, answering John's request to fix online video's dependence on advertising, introduces Subbable, a pay-what-you-want subscription system launching with Crash Course, and argues that advertisers value views rather than viewers, so Nerdfighteria could drive a cultural shift to voluntary payment.
What is said
00:00:00 — John's request to fix advertising during his paternity leave; Hank's fake announcement of 'Super Cardio Brothers'
- ★★ Hank recalls John saying months ago that nearly everything online depends on advertising, which undervalues the creator-viewer relationship, and asking Hank to fix this during his paternity leave. (playful) — 00:00:00 · John Green, online advertising
- ★★ The description says advertising does not care how viewers feel; the brothers fear distracting content will become the norm and loved content rare, and Subbable is their attempt to slow or stop that. (hedged) — 00:00:00 · online advertising
00:00:33 — The problem: advertisers value views, not viewers; no technological fix, but a cultural one, with Nerdfighteria as activation energy and Subbable as catalyst
- ★★★ Hank says the problem, as someone on Twitter put it, is that advertisers value views, not viewers: they only care that you are watching, not how much you care. — 00:00:37 · online advertising, Twitter > «advertisers value views, not viewers.»
- ★★★ Hank says he cannot solve this alone; the advertising system is too ingrained for a technological solution, but 'we' might find a cultural one. (hedged) — 00:00:47 · online advertising
- ★★★ Cultural changes need activation energy and catalysts; Hank feels Nerdfighteria, now a powerful force, could be the activation energy and Subbable the catalyst. (hedged) — 00:01:00 · Nerdfighteria
00:01:12 — How Subbable works (choose your price, perks); launch with Crash Course, whose Google grant is ending; Crash Course stays free on YouTube
- ★★★ Subbable lets you subscribe to content and choose what to pay: $0, $1, $5 or $100 a month, or a one-time amount. — 00:01:12
- ★★ Subscribers get videos and other content in their feed, possibly some exclusive content, without having to pay. (hedged) — 00:01:26
- ★★ Money spent is banked in Subbable and traded for perks for that project, such as a signed poster, a mention in an episode, or a message to a loved one in the description. — 00:01:33
- ★★★ Subbable launches with only Crash Course, the brothers' educational show, which is very expensive to make. — 00:01:45 · Crash Course
- ★★★ The Google grant that paid for Crash Course for the last two years is ending; without Subbable and its fans' support they cannot keep making it. — 00:01:50 · Google, Crash Course
- ★★★ Hank says educational content cannot get the 'bajillion' views needed to pay for itself through advertising. (playful) — 00:01:58 · online advertising, Crash Course
- ★★★ Crash Course will stay free on YouTube; the hope is that enough people who can pay will, so that everyone can have access. (hedged) — 00:02:03 · Crash Course, YouTube
00:02:13 — The ask: pay for content because you want to; a cultural shift toward engaging rather than distracting content
- ★★★ Hank asks viewers, which he calls weird, to pay for content because they want to, not because they are forced to: a cultural shift. — 00:02:13
- ★★ Educating the world for free takes money; Hank thinks the cultural change will lead to much more engaging content that people love rather than merely distracting content. (hedged) — 00:02:22 · online advertising
00:02:38 — Credits to the developer and designer and to Nerdfighteria; John returns Tuesday; subbable.com and 'defy capitalism'
- ★★ Hank credits developer Peter Jaros, designer Andrew Willis and the support of Nerdfighteria for making Subbable possible. — 00:02:38 · Nerdfighteria
- ★★ Hank says sharing the channel with many people during John's paternity leave over the last few weeks has been wonderful, but he is relieved John returns on Tuesday. — 00:02:48 · John Green
- ★★ Hank spells out subbable.com and asks viewers to go there, help fund Crash Course, and 'defy capitalism'. (playful) — 00:02:59 · Crash Course
Threads in this video
- result · John asks Hank to fix online video's dependence on advertising during his paternity leave (2013) — Hank recounts John's request (voiced comically) that he fix online content's dependence on advertising during John's paternity leave, and presents Subbable as his answer. (00:00:12)
- restate · Is ad-supported media good for audiences and society? — Hank: advertisers value views, not viewers; they only care that you are watching, and educational content cannot earn enough through ads. (00:00:37)
- launch · Subbable: launch of the brothers' pay-what-you-want subscription service, starting with Crash Course (2013) — Hank launches Subbable: subscribe to content and pay what you choose ($0 up, monthly or one-time), with perks for money banked; it launches with Crash Course only, whose Google grant is ending. (00:01:12)
- refine · How should online creators be paid: ads, sponsorships, paywalls or direct audience support? — Hank: content should stay free for all, with viewers who can choosing to pay because they want to, not because they are forced to. (00:02:13)
- update · John's paternity leave from vlogbrothers, with guest hosts filling in (2013) — Hank says it has been wonderful to share the channel with many people during John's paternity leave and that John returns on Tuesday. (00:02:53)
- open · Hank asks viewers to fund Crash Course through Subbable (2013) — Hank asks viewers who can to pay for Crash Course through subbable.com: 'help us fund Crash Course and defy capitalism'. (00:03:03)
BR2_3434318df7