Skip to content

How should online creators be paid: ads, sponsorships, paywalls or direct audience support?

Axis: direct audience support, no paywall, little sponsorship ... ads and brand deals are fine

John

date change position video
2009-07-15 new John says selling their books and Hank's CD isn't selling out and they take ads and sell t-shirts, but they do no paid product placement and would never imply Nerdfighters must buy things. Sell Outs! 00:02:07
2010-10-22 restate The description says the brothers accept no paid product placement precisely so viewers never have to wonder whether a product appears because it paid. Making Adorable Music 00:00:00
2012-02-14 restate John favours direct connections between makers and fans (Kickstarter, Gumroad) over middlemen such as venture capitalists, record companies, PayPal, Amazon or iTunes. Things I Can Do 00:02:26
2012-05-22 restate John says the brothers have never been totally comfortable with ads, but they have felt like the best way to make what they like with people they like. You ARE The Product 00:02:27
2012-06-01 restate John (apparently) says they don't do product placement so viewers can know no corporation (here Table Topics) is behind a video. Adorable Squirrel and Table Topics 00:00:00
2013-03-20 refine John rejects paywalls, finds Kickstarter and all-volunteer models ill-suited to ongoing channels, likes merchandise, and holds up the public radio model of asking rather than requiring support. Ads Work...but for Whom? 00:03:09

Hank

date change position video
2009-07-18 new Hank says ads and selling stuff both pay for more time on the videos, but the brothers far prefer selling stuff, since ads feel a little dirty, and nobody should feel obliged to buy. Selling Out, Chewbacca and Taking Leave 00:00:41
2009-11-24 new Hank says selling the things he has made through his creative work is not selling out; unlike pharmaceuticals or soda, he sells stuff he is proud of. 50 THINGS!! That I'm Thankful For 00:01:44
2011-03-25 restate Hank will keep ads on the videos, since otherwise he could not make them, believing the entertainment outweighs the ads' harm. Hank is an Adorable, Drunk Princess 00:02:21
2011-04-22 restate Hank says the brothers do few sponsored videos because they have their own things to sell. 500,000 Subscribers (Almost...and Thank You) 00:03:21
2013-03-15 refine Hank wants to change the business model of content because advertising cannot sustain dedicated mid-sized communities such as the Brain Scoop's 50,000. Ch-Ch-Ch-Ch-Changes 00:02:48
2013-05-17 restate Hank favours people making money from their content via YouTube paid subscriptions but says he and John will never paywall their own content. GIFs, JIFs, Whip Pans, Trivia, and BATMAN! 00:01:22
2013-05-24 restate Hank says Vlogbrothers has no pre-roll ads because the brothers feel deeply indebted to viewers, their only asset. What's Up with Start Ups 00:02:31
2013-07-26 refine Hank: content should stay free for all, with viewers who can choosing to pay because they want to, not because they are forced to. Introducing Subbable 00:02:13