Skip to content

Is doing nothing a choice, or are passive non-choices still choices?

John said in 2019 that passive choices are still choices, and in 2022 that skipping a cost-benefit analysis means making unconscious choices. Hank calls this true but exhausting to live by, and in 2022 said not picking up trash is half the reason it is there.

Axis: doing nothing is a choice one owns ... passive non-choices are not really choices

Positions by date: 4 records in 4 videos. The position was refined (2022), never reversed, in these records.

John

date how position video
2019-04-16 first on record John says passive choices are also choices: not taking prescribed medication is a choice, and an unwise one; staying home to watch Netflix is a choice too. Doing Somethings 00:01:56
2022-02-01 restate John says that if he thinks he transcends cost-benefit analysis by doing it all, he is still making choices, just unconscious ones. This Video Is Actually Three Videos 00:01:07

Hank

date how position video
2019-04-19 first on record Hank calls John's point absolutely true but says he can't imagine the world that way; it sounds exhausting. Making your Nothings into Somethings 00:02:53
2022-05-20 refine Hank says the person who dropped the trash is only half the reason it is there; the other half is that he did not pick it up. He is not equally morally responsible, but cares about the trash, not morality. It's My Fault Too 00:00:58