Nerdfighter MARRIAGE PROPOSAL
2009-06-30 · Q&A · John, Paul DeGeorge, Kelly · 3:05 · watch on YouTube
Topic: Nerdfighteria · mode: Q&A & conversation · tags: community lore, guest or collab, recurring series
On a Question Tuesday opened by Paul DeGeorge of Harry and the Potters, John answers viewer questions and, at a Nerdfighter's request, phones the viewer's girlfriend and asks her to marry him; she says yes.
What is said
The parts of the video and what is said in each (★ — how much it matters to the video).
00:00:00 — Question Tuesday opened by Paul DeGeorge; Harry and the Potters plug; fitness challenge progress; Spanish editions question
- ★★ John says Paul DeGeorge, half of Harry and the Potters, was in his house, and tells Nerdfighters who do not know the band that their lives are about to get better. — 00:00:00 · Nerdfighteria
- ★★ John says he has lost about three pounds in the fitness challenge but expects Hank to win the BMI part, so he must focus on running and push-ups. (playful, hedged) — 00:00:00 · Hank Green
00:00:39 — Buscando a Alaska; objects on the shelf and Willy's likeness; a request to propose; John's own proposal via Hertzberg
- ★ Asked whether his books are available in Spanish, John says yes: Looking for Alaska as Buscando a Alaska. — 00:00:39 · Looking for Alaska (novel)
- ★ Asked about an object behind his head, John runs through a My Little Pony, wooden shoes from Dutch fans and a sculpture of Willy as the Dread Pirate Fireball Wilson Roberts. (playful) — 00:00:39 · Willy
- ★★ Asked to propose for a viewer, John says Nerdfighters sometimes meet, fall in 'nerdfighter-like' and occasionally love, but he is unsure about proposing to someone other than his wife. (playful) — 00:00:39 · nerdfighterlike (coinage), Nerdfighteria
- ★★ John recalls that he did not ask the Yeti to marry him himself: he had Hendrik Hertzberg do it when signing John's copy of his book Politics. — 00:00:39 · Sarah Urist Green
00:01:25 — John phones a viewer's girlfriend on the viewer's behalf and asks her to marry him; she says yes
- ★★★ John phones the requesting viewer's girlfriend, apologises for misspelling her name when he signed her book, then asks whether she will marry her boyfriend; she says yes. — 00:01:25
- ★ John says he is more nervous than when he asked a girl to prom, and afterwards shaking with excitement. (playful) — 00:01:25
00:02:49 — Thanks to the couple for being made of awesome; sign-off
- ★★ John congratulates the couple, thanks them for being made of awesome and part of the community, and closes the call with 'best wishes'. — 00:02:49 · made of awesome, Nerdfighteria, best wishes
Humor (significant)
-
The Question Tuesday greeting is spoken in someone else's voice. — 00:00:00
“Okay, that wasn't me. It was Paul DeGeorge of Harry and the Potters.”
-
John says he must focus on running and push-ups to win the fitness challenge. — 00:00:00
“And anytime that I have to rely on push-ups, I'm in a bit of a pickle.”
-
A viewer asks whether the thing behind John is a polar bear with a top hat. — 00:00:39
“Do you mean the My Little Pony with a hand-painted black Santa on its bottom?”
-
A viewer asks John to propose to his girlfriend for him. — 00:00:39
“I don't know if I'm prepared to propose to someone other than my wife.”
Threads in this video
- kept · John: do a Question Tuesday on Tuesday, June 30 (2009) — John holds the promised Question Tuesday, answering Nerdfighters' questions. (00:00:00)
- result reported · John asks Nerdfighters to leave questions for his June 30 Question Tuesday (2009) — On Question Tuesday John answers questions Nerdfighters left, including a request to propose for a viewer. (00:00:00)
- retold · John proposes to Sarah with a book inscribed by Hendrik Hertzberg (2008) — John recalls that he did not propose to the Yeti himself: he had Hendrik Hertzberg do it when signing John's copy of his book Politics. (00:00:39)
- callback · John's 'Best wishes!' phone-call sign-off (2008) — John ends his proposal phone call with 'best wishes', his known phone-call sign-off. (00:02:49)
- callback · John's wife Sarah as 'the Yeti' (2007) — John recalls that he did not ask the Yeti to marry him himself: he had Hendrik Hertzberg do it when signing John's copy of his book Politics. (00:00:39)
- callback · John's coinage 'nerdfighter-like' for Nerdfighter romance (2007) — Asked to propose for a viewer, John says Nerdfighters sometimes meet, fall in 'nerdfighter-like' and occasionally love, but he is unsure about proposing to someone other than his wife. (00:00:39)
- callback · Willy as the Dread Pirate Fireball Wilson Roberts (2008) — Asked about an object behind his head, John runs through a My Little Pony, wooden shoes from Dutch fans and a sculpture of Willy as the Dread Pirate Fireball Wilson Roberts. (00:00:39)
- told · The Nerdfighter couple John proposed for on air in 2009: marriage and first child (2009) — John phones the requesting viewer's girlfriend, apologises for misspelling her name when he signed her book, then asks whether she will marry her boyfriend; she says yes. (00:01:25)
Where the stories that moved here went next
- John asks Nerdfighters to leave questions for his June 30 Question Tuesday (2009) — reported back; last: result reported, 2009-06-30
- John: do a Question Tuesday on Tuesday, June 30 (2009) — kept
- The Nerdfighter couple John proposed for on air in 2009: marriage and first child (2009) — told 2×, last update 2015; last: retold, 2015-01-13
Mentioned
Central: Kelly · Phil
Also: People: Hendrik Hertzberg · Paul DeGeorge · Sarah Urist Green
Projects: Nerdfighter Fitness Challenge
Works: Looking for Alaska (novel) · Politics: Observations & Arguments
Groups: Harry and the Potters
Rituals: Question Tuesday
Terms: best wishes · link in the sidebar · made of awesome · nerdfighterlike (coinage)
Concepts: Body mass index
animal: Willy
Only in the description or credits: Best Wishes from NL
Later videos replying to this one
- 2011-04-06 · Tales of Nerd Love! (John) — continues (update on The Nerdfighter couple John proposed for on air in 2009: marriage and first child (2009)) — John shows a flashback of his 2009 on-air marriage proposal for a Nerdfighter and reports the couple are now married and expecting their first child. (00:00:26)