Question Tuesday: TFIOS Movie, Existential Crises, and Symbolism
2014-03-11 · Q&A · John · 3:40 · watch on YouTube
Topic: Books & writing (also: Nerdfighteria, Science & nature, Projects, Pop culture, Sports) · mode: Q&A & conversation · tags: recurring series, self promotion, community lore
John answers viewer questions: he loves the TFIOS film, reading correlates with empathy, The Art Assignment recalls early Vlogbrothers, and writers use symbols to make abstract ideas observable and powerful.
What is said
The parts of the video and what is said in each (★ — how much it matters to the video).
00:00:00 — Greeting; Question Tuesday
00:00:04 — Why Hamlet's father is named Hamlet; next week's Crash Course Literature
- ★★ Answering why Hamlet's father is also named Hamlet ('old-fashioned Shakespearean doubling'), John says it will be discussed in detail in next week's (week of 17 March 2014) Crash Course Literature. — 00:00:06 · Crash Course
00:00:11 — Is the TFIOS movie actually good? John loves it
- ★★★ Asked if he really thinks the TFIOS film is good, John says he'd find nice things to say even if he didn't like it, but in fact he loves it, though he might be wrong and isn't objective. (hedged) — 00:00:16 · The Fault in Our Stars (film), The Fault in Our Stars
00:00:33 — Are readers more empathetic? Studies on literary fiction
- ★★ John says studies show a correlation between empathy and reading, at least for literary fiction. — 00:00:36 · empathy
00:00:40 — Elbows; 'I don't watch your videos'; staring into the void; the ocean
- ★ John calls 'I don't watch your videos, why should I?' a terrible Question Tuesday question, since such a viewer by definition won't hear his answer. (playful) — 00:00:47 · Question Tuesday
00:01:15 — More stars in the universe or grains of sand on Earth?
- ★★ John thinks there are more stars in the universe than grains of sand on Earth, calling it a beautiful question that makes him grateful to apprehend the universe; more info in the description. (hedged) — 00:01:19 · doobly-doo
00:01:34 — Participating in The Art Assignment: like early Vlogbrothers
- ★★★ John says participating in The Art Assignment is the most fun he has had in a long time, like early Vlogbrothers: a tight-knit community doing projects and responding to each other's work. — 00:01:36 · The Art Assignment, Vlogbrothers
00:01:47 — Excited for the Divergent movie
- ★ John says he is 'already-bought-my-tickets-for-opening-day' excited for the Divergent film, two weeks away. (playful) — 00:01:50
00:01:53 — Predictions for the IndyCar season
- ★★ Revealing he is a secret IndyCar fan, John predicts Tony Kanaan will win the Indy 500 for the second time and Will Power will take the series title. (hedged) — 00:01:58
00:02:06 — DFTBA in French
00:02:13 — Why writers use symbolism: metaphor, the green light, making the abstract observable
- ★★ On why writers use symbolism, John says a metaphor like 'my brain is on fire' is used so a serious headache can be understood as one needing attention. — 00:02:14
-
★★★ John says symbols apply the same imagistic principle to complex ideas, like yearning across the bay for the green light while class stands in the way, making the abstract observable and more powerful. — 00:02:31
“when you talk about it symbolically, it becomes more powerful because instead of being abstract, it becomes kind of observable”
00:03:05 — Best butt (Wil Wheaton's); dreaming of being a pizza
00:03:29 — Most excited about: The Art Assignment; asks viewers; sign-off
- ★★ John says he is most excited right now about The Art Assignment and asks viewers to say in comments what they are most excited about. — 00:03:34 · The Art Assignment
Humor (significant)
-
Asked where he stands on elbows, — 00:00:42
“I don't; I only stand on my feet.”
-
Wondering how to reach people not inside the camera, John decides no one may be in there and he is staring into the void. — 00:01:06
“Oh god, I feel an existential crisis coming on.”
-
Asked who has the best butt, him or Hank, John says neither. — 00:03:07
“the best butt I've ever personally seen is actually Wil Wheaton's.”
-
Asked if he ever dreamed of being a pizza, John says it would be a nightmare: smelling and tasting like pizza, but — 00:03:19
“if you eat yourself, you will die and ergo not be able to ever eat pizza again.”
Threads in this video
- repeated · John predicts The Fault in Our Stars movie will be a good movie (2013) — Having seen it, John restates that the TFIOS film is good: he loves it, while granting he might be wrong and is not objective. (00:00:27)
- predicted · John: Tony Kanaan will win the Indy 500 for the second time (2014) — John predicts Tony Kanaan will win the Indy 500 for the second time. (00:01:58)
- predicted · John: Will Power will win the IndyCar series title (2014) — John predicts Will Power will win the IndyCar series title. (00:02:02)
- asked · John asks viewers to say in comments what they're most excited about right now (2014) — John asks viewers to say in comments what they are most excited about right now. (00:03:34)
Where the stories that moved here went next
- John: Tony Kanaan will win the Indy 500 for the second time (2014) — unresolved; last: predicted, 2014-03-11
- John: Will Power will win the IndyCar series title (2014) — unresolved; last: predicted, 2014-03-11
Mentioned
Central: close reading · The Art Assignment · The Fault in Our Stars (film)
Also: People: Ansel Elgort · Rik Smits · Tony Kanaan · Wil Wheaton · Will Power
Projects: Crash Course
Works: Divergent (film) · Hamlet (play) · The Fault in Our Stars · The Great Gatsby
Rituals: Question Tuesday
Terms: DFTBA · doobly-doo
Concepts: empathy · existential crisis · metaphor
Events: Indianapolis 500 · IndyCar Series
Characters: green light
Also centred on close reading: The Return of Question Tuesdays · OMFG CATCHER IN THE RYE!!! · The Catcher in the Rye, Part 2 · Life Is Like Pizza · Question Tuesday! Paula Deen Riding Me (and critical reading)
← Previous: Thoughts from a Cruise · Next → Sexual Abuse, Consent, and Culture