What is That Plane Rainbow? (It's Question Tuesday)
2018-02-02 · Q&A · Hank · 3:50 · watch on YouTube
Topic: Books & writing (also: Nerdfighteria, Science & nature, Personal life, Pop culture) · mode: Q&A & conversation · tags: recurring series, self promotion, community lore
In a Question Tuesday held on a Friday, Hank answers Twitter questions: he recommends Octavia Butler's Dawn, reports stressful editing of An Absolutely Remarkable Thing (out September 25th), explains glories and Brocken spectres, sings a text message and picks an Elton John outfit.
What is said
The parts of the video and what is said in each (★ — how much it matters to the video).
00:00:00 — Question Tuesday on a Friday; questions from Twitter; are numbers real?
- ★ Hank holds Question Tuesday on a Friday, complaining that John always gets to do question videos just because he posts on Tuesdays. (playful) — 00:00:04 · Question Tuesday, John Green
- ★ Hank's first question from Twitter is whether numbers are real or made up; he balks that they started out hard when question videos should be easier. (playful, hedged) — 00:00:14 · Twitter
00:00:21 — Best recent book: Octavia Butler's Dawn and its TV adaptation by Ava DuVernay
- ★★ Hank often avoids promoting books by dead authors, because so many great books are being written by people working right now. — 00:00:25
- ★★★ Hank's best recent read is Dawn by Octavia Butler, part of the Xenogenesis trilogy. — 00:00:33
- ★★ Hank says Dawn is being made into a TV series by Ava DuVernay, shockingly the first time an Octavia Butler work has been adapted for TV or film. — 00:00:38
- ★★ Hank says Dawn is very good and gives enormous insight into what it is like to be human and what 'human' means. — 00:00:48
00:01:01 — Book editing stress, an emoji for the book, release date, staying informed without stress
- ★★ Asked how book editing is going, Hank says not great: a busy week, a deadline he may miss, and a lot of stress. (hedged) — 00:01:01 · An Absolutely Remarkable Thing
- ★★ Asked for an official emoji combination for his book, Hank asks people to come up with one and promises to return to it at the end of the video. — 00:01:17 · An Absolutely Remarkable Thing
- ★★ Hank's book An Absolutely Remarkable Thing is available for pre-order now and comes out on September 25th. — 00:01:21 · An Absolutely Remarkable Thing
- ★ Asked how to stay informed about current events without stress, Hank says everyone would like to know the answer if the asker figures it out. (hedged) — 00:01:27
00:01:35 — What Hank did after finishing his first book: an accordionist in the airport, flying home from PodCon
- ★★ After finishing his first book, Hank watched a French man play accordion in an airport while his children played, thinking that weird things happen both in his book and in the real world, then flew home. — 00:01:35
00:01:57 — The rainbow under the plane wing: glories and Brocken spectres
- ★★ Hank says the rainbow seen under a plane wing is a glory: like a rainbow, an effect of light diffracting on water droplets, but with smaller droplets. — 00:01:57
- ★★ Hank says a glory is seen only from between the sun and the cloud, so rarely from the ground; before planes, glories were seen mostly from mountaintops. — 00:02:07
- ★★ Hank says mountaintop observers were often inside the cloud's fog, so besides the glory they saw a Brocken spectre, very cool and super creepy. — 00:02:20
00:02:36 — Hank sings his last text message: Julie's birthday and recording DadCast
- ★★ Singing his last text message, from Marianne, Hank learns it is Julie's birthday and confirms he can record DadCast on Monday; he thanks Marianne for keeping his life in order. (playful) — 00:02:38
00:02:58 — Which Elton John outfit Hank would wear
- ★★ After googling Elton John outfits, Hank picks the one he calls Sparkly Banana Beetlejuice. (playful, hedged) — 00:03:27 · Google
00:03:30 — Emoji sequences for the book from Katherine and April May; sign-off
- ★★ For the book's emoji sequence, Hank reports Katherine has one with spoilers and April May suggests robot, dark-haired white girl, Statue of Liberty, burrito. (playful) — 00:03:33 · Katherine Green, An Absolutely Remarkable Thing
Humor (significant)
-
Hank's first Twitter question asks whether numbers are real or made up; he stalls and whispers. — 00:00:14
“I feel like we started out hard!”
-
Asked to sing his last text message, Hank sings the reminder from Marianne. — 00:02:38
“Good morning to things!”
-
Googling Elton John outfits, Hank describes his favourite. — 00:03:15
“Beetlejuice, but with a sparkly banana.”
-
Hank now wants an Elton John outfit review podcast, but admits one shortcoming. — 00:03:23
“I definitely cannot compete with the chest hair.”
Threads in this video
- update · Hank writes An Absolutely Remarkable Thing, his first novel (2014) — Asked how book editing is going, Hank says not great: a busy week, a deadline he may miss, and a lot of stress. (00:01:01)
- asked · Hank asks people for an official emoji sequence for An Absolutely Remarkable Thing (2018) — Asked for an official emoji combination for his book, Hank asks people to come up with one and says he will return to it at the end of the video. (00:01:17)
- result reported · Hank asks people for an official emoji sequence for An Absolutely Remarkable Thing (2018) — Hank reports that Katherine has an emoji sequence with spoilers and April May suggests robot, dark-haired white girl, Statue of Liberty, burrito. (00:03:33)
- retold · Hank writes An Absolutely Remarkable Thing, his first novel (2014) — After finishing his first book, Hank watched a French man play accordion in an airport while his children played, thinking that weird things happen both in his book and in the real world, then flew home. (00:01:35)
- milestone · An Absolutely Remarkable Thing: announcement and publication of Hank's first novel (2017) — Hank's book An Absolutely Remarkable Thing is available for pre-order now and comes out on September 25th. (00:01:21)
- reminder · Hank asks viewers to pre-order An Absolutely Remarkable Thing (2018) — Hank's book An Absolutely Remarkable Thing is available for pre-order now and comes out on September 25th. (00:01:21)
Where the stories that moved here went next
- Hank asks people for an official emoji sequence for An Absolutely Remarkable Thing (2018) — reported back; last: result reported, 2018-02-02
- An Absolutely Remarkable Thing: announcement and publication of Hank's first novel (2017) — completed; last: looked back, 2025-12-09
- Hank writes An Absolutely Remarkable Thing, his first novel (2014) — told 5×, last update 2024; last: retold, 2024-08-07
Mentioned
Central: Dawn (Butler novel) · Glory (optical phenomenon)
Also: People: Ava DuVernay · Elton John · Julie · Katherine Green · Marie Ann
Projects: PodCon
Works: An Absolutely Remarkable Thing · DadCast · Lilith's Brood
Organizations: Google · Twitter
Rituals: Question Tuesday
Concepts: Brocken spectre · rainbow
Characters: April May
Only in the description or credits: Octavia E. Butler
← Previous: Hank, I Have Some Advice · Next → Sawdust Bread