I Don't Understand My Life
2012-08-03 · letter vlog · Hank, Kimya Dawson · 3:39 · watch on YouTube
Topic: Philosophy & meaning (also: Nerdfighteria, Personal life) · mode: Personal essay · tags: calendar ritual, community lore, timely hook, civic or action cta, guest or collab, fundraising ask
On Esther Day Hank answers a commenter who felt worthless watching Olympic gymnasts: value is something people give each other, the value we bring comes from whom we love and who loves us, so say 'I love you' to people you don't usually say it to.
What is said
The parts of the video and what is said in each (★ — how much it matters to the video).
00:00:00 — Title card greeting
00:00:06 — Happy Esther Day; things Hank doesn't understand about his life (Pinches's sign, Kimya Dawson buying a shirt, stage dive), with Kimya's cameo
- ★★ Hank says he sometimes doesn't understand his life: the Olympic gymnast and Nerdfighter signing to millions, Kimya Dawson buying a Nerdfighter shirt from him without his knowing, and his diving off a stage into a crowd. — 00:00:08
- ★ Kimya Dawson: In a cameo, Kimya Dawson answers that she doesn't understand her life either. (playful) — 00:00:26
- ★ Hank thinks not understanding our own lives is probably universal. (hedged) — 00:00:30
00:00:35 — The top comment on John's video and Hank's answer: value is given by people; shot put; what matters is loving and being loved, even for Olympians
- ★★ Hank reads the top comment (93 thumbs up) on John's last video: watching gymnasts their own age made a viewer ask what they are doing with their life, and that feeling sucks. — 00:00:35
- ★★★ Hank argues gymnastics scoring and appreciation aren't universal: the Olympics has value only because people come together and give it value. — 00:00:52 · social construction
- ★★ Without people watching and valuing it, shot put would just be a guy in a field throwing a rock, a crazy person. (playful) — 00:01:02 · social construction
- ★★ When people say they're not doing anything with their life, Hank hears that they think they're doing nothing of value. — 00:01:16
- ★★★ Though often literally and figuratively on a stage, what matters most to Hank is how much he loves people and how much the people he loves love him. — 00:01:23
- ★★ Jennifer Pinches, Kyla Ross and McKayla Maroney want to compete and win gold, but most of all, like all people, they want to be loved by those they love. — 00:01:37
- ★★ Reading that comment this week (week of 30 July 2012) made Esther's message hit home for Hank harder than ever. — 00:01:59 · Esther Earl
00:02:07 — Who Esther Earl was and how she chose the meaning of Esther Day
- ★★ Esther Earl was a Nerdfighter the brothers met in 2009 at the first LeakyCon; she and her friends were and remain very important to Nerdfighteria; she had lived with cancer a long time. — 00:02:08 · Esther Earl, Nerdfighteria
- ★★★ When Esther was really sick, John told her the brothers wanted to celebrate her birthday every year the channel existed; after about two weeks she chose a day for saying 'I love you' to family and friends. — 00:02:19 · Esther Earl, John Green, Vlogbrothers, Esther Day
00:02:52 — The value you bring comes from love; a gold medal in love for saying 'I love you'; Esthertines
- ★★★ To the 93 people who upvoted the comment and others who feel that way: the value you bring to the world comes largely from what you love and who loves you. — 00:02:52
- ★★★ This Esther Day viewers 'get a gold medal in love' if they say 'I love you' to people they don't usually say it to; don't take love for granted or assume people know how you feel. — 00:03:03 · Esther Day, Esther Earl
- ★★ A Nerdfighter made Nerdfighter-themed Esthertines that work for anybody, best delivered by hand with a note on why you love them; Hank is going to give Katherine hers. — 00:03:15 · Katherine Green
00:03:29 — Thanks to Nerdfighteria; sign-off
- ★ Hank thanks Nerdfighteria for spreading these ideas and making the world suck less, more awesome and a little weirder. — 00:03:29 · Nerdfighteria, world suck
Threads in this video
- asked · Hank invites viewers to donate to This Star Won't Go Out on Esther Day (2012) — The description invites viewers to give to This Star Won't Go Out on Esther Day. (video description)
- reminder · John asks Nerdfighters to buy This Star Won't Go Out bracelets at DFTBA.com/Esther (2010) — The description invites viewers to get a This Star Won't Go Out bracelet at DFTBA.com. (video description)
- restate · Can things that humans made up (sports, money, borders, rules) really matter? — Hank: the Olympics (and gymnastics, shot put) have value because people come together and give them value. (00:00:58)
- restate · Does human life have real meaning, given oblivion, cosmic scale and an indifferent universe? — Hank: what matters most, and the value a person brings to the world, comes from loving people and being loved by them. (00:01:32)
- looked back · Esther Day: the brothers' annual videos on Esther Earl's birthday about what she chooses (2010) — Hank retells Esther Day's origin: when Esther was really sick, John told her the brothers wanted to celebrate her birthday yearly, and she chose a day for saying 'I love you' to family and friends. (00:02:19)
- reminder · John asks Nerdfighters to tell someone they love that they love them on Esther Day (2010) — Hank repeats the Esther Day ask: say 'I love you' to people you don't usually say it to, and don't assume they know how you feel. (00:03:06)
- looked back · LeakyCon 2009 edition — Esther Earl was a Nerdfighter the brothers met in 2009 at the first LeakyCon; she and her friends were and remain very important to Nerdfighteria; she had lived with cancer a long time. (00:02:08)
Where the stories that moved here went next
- Hank invites viewers to donate to This Star Won't Go Out on Esther Day (2012) — asked again in 9 years (2012–2023); last: reminder, 2023-08-03
Mentioned
Central: Esther Day · Esther Earl · Olympic Games · social construction
Also: People: Jennifer Pinches · Katherine Green · Kimya Dawson · Kyla Ross · McKayla Maroney
Works: Esthertines
Rituals: Nerdfighter gang sign
Terms: world suck
Concepts: gymnastics · shot put
Events: LeakyCon · Valentine's Day
Only in the description or credits: This Star Won't Go Out (charity)
Also centred on Olympic Games: Happy Third Chocolate Day! · 16 Sports that Should Be in the Olympics · I Have Uncovered an Olympics Mystery… · The Olympics Mystery Explained!!!
Replies to
- continues · Nerd Olympics — “John, when I watched your last video, the top comment had 93 thumbs up.”
← Previous: Nerd Olympics · Next → EXTRA! Thoughts from Tour